Last 12 Months - Best/Worst PPV Performers

Took a dive back through the last 12 months of WO PPV feedback (October 2011 - October 2012). Based on this data, it would suggest: ROH Kings are Davey Richards, Kevin Steen and Adam Cole TNA Winners are AJ Styles, Kurt Angle, Christopher Daniels, Austin Aries, Kazarian and Bobby Roode WWE Superstars are CM Punk, John Cena, Daniel Bryan and Dolph Ziggler Best Match Honors Ring of Honor Davey Richards: 5 matches Kevin Steen: 5 matches Adam Cole: 3 matches Michael Elgin: 2 matches Kyle O’Reilly: 2 matches El Generico: 1 match Mike Mondo: 1 match Mike Bennett: 1 match Eddie Edwards: 1 match Rhino: 1 match Lance Storm: 1 match TNA AJ Styles: 8 matches Kurt Angle: 7 matches Christopher Daniels: 7 matches Austin Aries: 6 matches Kazarian: 5 matches Bobby Roode: 5 matches Jeff Hardy: 3 matches Samoa Joe: 3 matches James Storm: 2 matches Mr Anderson: 1 match Kid Kash: 1 match Hernandez: 1 match Brutus Magnus: 1 match Alex Shelley: 1 match Bully Ray: 1 match Zema Ion: 1 match Abyss: 1 match Chavo Guerrero Jr: 1 match Jesse Sorensen: 1 match WWE CM Punk: 12 matches John Cena: 8 matches Daniel Bryan: 6 matches Dolph Ziggler: 6 matches Chris Jericho: 4 matches the Big Show: 4 matches Alberto Del Rio: 4 matches Sheamus: 3 matches the Miz: 3 matches Mark Henry: 2 matches the Rock: 2 matches Kane: 2 matches R-Truth: 2 matches Cody Rhodes: 2 matches Santino Marella: 2 matches Brock Lesnar: 2 matches Christian: 2 matches HHH: 2 matches Sin Cara: 1 match Damien Sandow: 1 match The Great Khali: 1 match Kofi Kingston: 1 match Lord Tensai: 1 match Tyson Kidd: 1 match the Undertaker: 1 match Wade Barrett: 1 match John Morrison: 1 match Worst Match Honors Ring of Honor Charlie Haas: 4 matches Shelton Benjamin: 3 matches Mike Bennett: 2 matches Mark Briscoe: 2 matches Rhett Titus: 2 matches Cedric Alexander: 2 matches Jay Briscoe: 2 matches Jimmy Jacobs: 2 matches Roderick Strong: 2 matches Rhino: 1 match Caprice Coleman: 1 match Kevin Steen: 1 match Fit Finlay: 1 match Dave Crist: 1 match Headbanger Mosh: 1 match Headbanger Thrasher: 1 match Tadarius Thomas: 1 match Homicide: 1 match Michael Elgin: 1 match Jake Crist: 1 match Mike Mondo: 1 match Adam Pearce: 1 match Adam Cole: 1 match Steve Corino: 1 match Kenny King: 1 match Tommaso Ciampa: 1 match TNA Bully Ray: 6 matches Crimson: 4 matches Miss Tessmacher: 4 matches Gail Kim: 4 matches Madison Rayne: 3 matches James Storm: 3 matches Devon: 3 matches Robbie E: 3 matches Garrett Bischoff: 3 matches Matt Morgan: 2 matches Mason Andrews: 2 matches Eric Young: 2 matches Gunner: 2 matches Tara: 2 matches Doug Williams: 1 match RVD: 1 match ODB: 1 match Lars Only: 1 match Christopher Daniels: 1 match Bobby Roode: 1 match Al Snow: 1 match Flip Casanova: 1 match Dakota Darsow: 1 match AJ Styles: 1 match Sting: 1 match Austin Aries: 1 match Velvet Sky: 1 match Eric Bischoff: 1 match Jigsaw: 1 match Mr Anderson: 1 match Joey Ryan: 1 match Rob Terry: 1 match Joseph Park: 1 match and Abyss: 1 match Rosita: 1 match Kazarian: 1 match Sarita: 1 match Kenny King: 1 match Kid Kash: 1 match Zema Ion: 1 match Jeff Hardy: 1 match WWE Beth Phoenix: 9 matches Eve Torres: 6 matches Layla: 4 matches the Big Show: 4 matches Mark Henry: 4 matches Dolph Ziggler: 4 matches R-Truth: 4 matches Ryback: 4 matches the Miz: 4 matches Kane: 4 matches Kofi Kingston: 3 matches Tamina Snuka: 3 matches John Cena: 3 matches Daniel Bryan: 3 matches Kelly Kelly: 4 matches Titus O’Neil: 2 matches Sheamus: 2 matches Brodus Clay: 2 matches Nikki Bella: 2 matches Sin Cara: 2 matches CM Punk: 2 matches Eric Young: 2 matches Drew McIntyre: 2 matches Jack Swagger: 2 matches Santino Marella: 2 matches Zack Ryder: 2 matches Epico: 1 match Cody Rhodes: 1 match Kevin Nash: 1 match Booker T: 1 match Alberto Del Rio: 1 match Ricardo Rodriguez: 1 match Curt Hawkins: 1 match Chris Jericho: 1 match Dan Delany: 1 match Jay Relic: 1 match Brie Bella: 1 match Justin Gabriel: 1 match David Otunga: 1 match Rob Grymes: 1 match Maria Menounos: 1 match Camacho: 1 match Brock Lesnar: 1 match HHH: 2 match Natalya: 1 match Jay Hatton: 1 match Natayla: 1 match The Great Khali: 1 match Alicia Fox: 1 match Tyler Reks: 1 match Primo: 1 match Randy Orton: 1 match John Laurinaitis: 1 match Kaitlyn: 1 match Now, this counting doesn'tt weighing the results towards the matches that dominated the best/worst voting. Here's something with that: If you take a proportion of best/worst votes over total votes for the PPV: i.e. 112 votes for Bound For Glory; 46 votes for Hardy/Aries as best match = 0.41 points for Jeff Hardy and Austin Aries. Scores: CM Punk: 6.80 out of 13 shows (very high) AJ Styles: 4.80 out of 11 shows (very high) Kurt Angle: 4.80 out of 11 shows (very high) Christopher Daniels: 3.39 out of 11 shows Daniel Bryan: 3.39 out of 13 shows John Cena: 3.35 out of 13 shows Austin Aries: 3.28 out of 11 shows Alberto Del Rio: 3.16 out of 13 shows Davey Richards: 3.09 out of 5 shows (very high) Bobby Roode: 2.69 out of 11 shows Kevin Steen: 2.58 out of 5 shows (very high) Kazarian: 2.53 out of 11 shows Jeff Hardy: 1.85 out of 11 shows Michael Elgin: 1.68 out of 5 shows (very high) Dolph Ziggler: 1.56 out of 13 shows Adam Cole: 1.50 out of 5 shows Kyle O’Reilly: 1.18 out of 5 shows HHH: 1.18 out of 13 shows TNA Events: TNA BOUND FOR GLORY PPV POLL RESULTS TNA NO SURRENDER PPV POLL RESULTS TNA HARDCORE JUSTICE PPV POLL RESULTS TNA DESTINATION X PPV POLL RESULTS TNA SLAMMIVERSARY PPV POLL RESULTS TNA SACRIFICE PPV POLL RESULTS TNA LOCKDOWN PPV POLL RESULTS TNA VICTORY ROAD PPV POLL RESULTS TNA AGAINST ALL ODDS PPV POLL RESULTS TNA GENESIS PPV POLL RESULTS TNA TURNING POINT PPV POLL RESULTS WWE Events: WWE NIGHT OF CHAMPIONS PPV POLL RESULTS WWE SUMMERSLAM PPV POLL RESULTS WWE MONEY IN THE BANK PPV POLL RESULTS WWE NO WAY OUT PPV POLL RESULTS WWE OVER THE LIMIT PPV POLL RESULTS WWE EXTREME RULES PPV POLL RESULTS WWE WRESTLEMANIA XXVIII PPV POLL RESULTS WWE ELIMINATION CHAMBER PPV POLL RESULTS WWE ROYAL RUMBLE PPV FEEDBACK WWE SURVIVOR SERIES PPV POLL RESULTS WWE VENGEANCE PPV POLL RESULTS WWE HELL IN A CELL PPV POLL RESULTS WWE TLC PPV POLL RESULTS (added) ROH Events: ROH GLORY BY HONOR IPPV POLL RESULTS ROH DEATH BEFORE DISHONOR IPPV POLL RESULTS ROH BEST IN THE WORLD IPPV POLL RESULTS ROH BORDER WARS IPPV POLL RESULTS ROH 10TH ANNIVERSARY IPPV POLL RESULTS CM Punk matches that were listed: WWE NIGHT OF CHAMPIONS PPV POLL RESULTS: C.M. Punk vs. John Cena 97 WWE SUMMERSLAM PPV POLL RESULTS: Punk vs. Show vs. Cena 8 WWE MONEY IN THE BANK PPV POLL RESULTS: C.M. Punk vs. Daniel Bryan 96 WWE NO WAY OUT PPV POLL RESULTS: Punk vs. Kane vs. Bryan 86 WWE OVER THE LIMIT PPV POLL RESULTS: C.M. Punk vs. Daniel Bryan 123 WWE EXTREME RULES PPV POLL RESULTS: C.M. Punk vs. Chris Jericho 45 WWE WRESTLEMANIA XXVIII PPV POLL RESULTS: C.M. Punk vs. Chris Jericho 87 WWE ELIMINATION CHAMBER PPV POLL RESULTS: Raw Chamber match 31 WWE ROYAL RUMBLE PPV FEEDBACK: C.M. Punk vs. Dolph Ziggler 151 WWE SURVIVOR SERIES PPV POLL RESULTS: C.M. Punk vs. Alberto Del Rio 104 WWE HELL IN A CELL PPV POLL RESULTS: Del Rio vs. Punk vs. Cena 58 The PPV that didn't have a Punk match listed in the Best match poll? He was actually in the running for worst match -- WWE VENGEANCE PPV POLL RESULTS: Miz & R-Truth vs. Punk & Miz 10 I only had 12 WWE PPVs listed and I knew I should have 13 - found the missing show: WWE TLC. WWE TLC PPV POLL RESULTS Thumbs up 85 (84.2%) Thumbs down 0 (00.0%) In the middle 16 (15.8%) BEST MATCH POLL Punk vs. Del Rio vs. Miz 99 WORST MATCH POLL Beth Phoenix vs. Kelly Kelly 40 Big Show vs. Mark Henry 35 HHH vs. Kevin Nash 26 So, another best match honors for Punk. I should point out that if more than one match was listed as BEST MATCH, they both were given credit - ditto with WORST MATCH. That shortcoming was sort of the premise behind the points system I noted at the end of my post - it's an attempt to attribute who had the majority of the votes for best match per show. In my mind, this is a pretty strong story for Best North American Wrestler for CM Punk. Yes, the issue of who gets most time is certainly skewed towards "main eventers"... for the most part (look at Santino).. Average time per match (Ranked) 1. CM Punk 2. Chris Jericho 3. Triple H 4. John Cena 5. Alberto Del Rio 6. Santino Marella 7. The Miz 8. R-Truth 9. Randy Orton 10. Daniel Bryan 11. Kane 12. Dolph Ziggler 13. Kofi Kingston 14. Sin Cara 15. Sheamus 16. Cody Rhodes 17. the Big Show 18. Christian 19. Jack Swagger 20. Mark Henry notes: I didn't include Rumble and I didn't time out for Elimination matches to allocate time I don't know if I realized the Ziggler has wrestled 15 matches in 13 PPVs: Hell in a Cell 2011 - New Orleans, LA - Arena - October 2, 2011: WWE Tag Team Champions Evan Bourne & Kofi Kingston defeated WWE US Tag Team Champion Dolph Ziggler & Jack Swagger (w/ Vickie Guerrero) at 11:18 when Bourne pinned Swagger with a hurricanrana as Swagger attempted a powerbomb off the top, while Kingston prevented Ziggler from making the save; after the match, Vickie yelled at Swagger for the loss Vengeance 2011 - San Antonio, TX - AT&T Center - October 23, 2011 (8,000): WWE Tag Team Champions Kofi Kingston & Evan Bourne defeated WWE US Champion Dolph Ziggler & Jack Swagger (w/ Vickie Guerrero) at 13:24 when Bourne pinned Ziggler with Air Bourne following Kingston's spin kick to the face Vengeance 2011 - San Antonio, TX - AT&T Center - October 23, 2011 (8,000): WWE US Champion Dolph Ziggler (w/ Vickie Guerrero & Jack Swagger) pinned Zack Ryder at 6:03 with a superkick after Ryder fought off an interfering Swagger Survivor Series 2011 - New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - November 20, 2011 (16,749; 13,000 paid; sell out): WWE US Champion Dolph Ziggler pinned John Morrison at 10:44 with the Zig Zag after avoiding the Starship Pain Survivor Series 2011 - New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - November 20, 2011 (16,749; 13,000 paid; sell out): Wade Barrett, Jack Swagger, WWE US Champion Dolph Ziggler, Hunico, & WWE IC Champion Cody Rhodes defeated Randy Orton, Sheamus, Sin Cara, Mason Ryan, & WWE Tag Team Champion Kofi Kingston in an elimination match at 22:11 TLC 2011 - Baltimore, MD - First Mariner Arena - December 18, 2011 (8,000): Zack Ryder pinned WWE US Champion Dolph Ziggler to win the title at 10:23 with the Rough Ryder Royal Rumble 2012 - St. Louis, MO - Scottrade Center - January 29, 2012 (18,121; 15,000 paid; sell out): WWE World Champion CM Punk pinned Dolph Ziggler with the Go To Sleep after a slingshot in the corner, with the challenger striking his head on the ringpost Elimination Chamber 2012 - Milwaukee, WI - Bradley Center - February 19, 2012 (15,306; sell out): WWE World Champion CM Punk defeated Chris Jericho, R-Truth, Kofi Kingston, Dolph Ziggler (w/ Vickie Guerrero), and Mike Mizanin in an Elimination Chamber match at 32:38 WrestleMania 28 - Miami, FL - Sun Life Stadium - April 1, 2012 (announced at 78,363): David Otunga, Mike Mizanin, Dolph Ziggler, Mark Henry, Drew McIntyre, & Jack Swagger (w/ John Laurinaitis & Vickie Guerrero) defeated WWE US Champion Santino Marella, Kofi Kingston, the Great Khali, R-Truth, Zack Ryder (w/ Eve), & Booker T (w/ Teddy Long, Aksana, & Hornswoggle) at 10:38 Extreme Rules 2012 - Chicago, IL - AllState Arena - April 29, 2012 (announced at 14,817): Brodus Clay (w/ Hornswoggle, Naomi, & Cameron) pinned Dolph Ziggler (w/ Vickie Guerrero & Jack Swagger) in an unadvertised bout at the 5-minute mark with a headbutt to the chest and splash; prior to the bout, Guerrero introduced Ziggler from the entrance stage; during the match, there were chants of "Let's go, Ziggler" Over the Limit 2012 - Raleigh, NC - RBC Center - May 20, 2012 (8,000): WWE Tag Team Champions R-Truth & Kofi Kingston defeated Dolph Ziggler & Jack Swagger (w/ Vickie Guerrero) at 12:17 when Kingston pinned Ziggler with the spin kick to the face as Ziggler ran into the corner; prior to the bout, Guerrero entroduced her team from the entrance stage and noted she would be the logical replacement for John Laurinaitis, should he be fired later in the show No Way Out 2012 - East Rutherford, NJ - Izod Center - June 17, 2012: World Heavyweight Champion Sheamus pinned Dolph Ziggler (w/ Vickie Guerrero) at 15:09 with the White Noise and boot to the face; the two received mixed reactions during the in-ring introductions, followed by chants of "Let's go, Ziggler" Money in the Bank 2012 - Phoenix, AZ - US Airways Center - July 15, 2012 (10,000): Dolph Ziggler defeated WWE IC Champion Christian, Cody Rhodes, Damien Sandow, WWE US Champion Santino Marella, Sin Cara, Tensai, and Tyson Kidd in a Money in the Bank match at 18:29 Summer Slam 2012 - Los Angeles, CA - Staples Center - August 19, 2012 (17,482; sell out): Chris Jericho defeated Dolph Ziggler (w/ Vickie Guerrero) at 13:04 via submission with the Walls of Jericho after Ziggler missed a charge in the corner; prior to the bout, Gurrero introduced Ziggler from the entrance stage; Jericho's ribs were heavily taped for the contest; during the match, there were dueling chants of "Y2J" and "Let's go, Ziggler" Night of Champions 2012 - Boston, MA - TD Garden - September 16, 2012: Randy Orton pinned Dolph Ziggler (w/ Vickie Guerrero)